In the words of new zealands mounted riflemen by terry kinloch the face of battle. The malayan emergency has long been presented as a rare counterinsurgency success story, one in which the insurgents were defeated and an independent, democratic and multiethnic state emerged. There is a massive literature on the history and theory of insurgency and counter insurgency. The nature of insurgency has changed since the 1950s, 60s and 70s. The communist insurgency in thailand was a guerrilla war lasting from 1965 until 1983, fought mainly by the communist party of thailand cpt and the government of thailand. Malaysias experience in war against communist insurgency and its. Experiences in malaya and vietnam study in international security first edition by thompson, sir robert isbn. The lessons of malaya and vietnam studies in international. The british had extensive experience with insurgents in malaya and offered to give america advice but it was not taken. Comparing counterinsurgency tactics in iraq and vietnam.
The british experience in defeating the communist insurgency in malaya, has always been cited as one of successful examples on how a government could win a low intensity conflict. Some more junior figures in the british establishment, especially. It is a persistently methodical approach and steady pressure which will gradually. Defeating communist insurgency cambridge university press. The lessons of malaya and vietnam sir robert thompson snippet view 1966. Examples of british counterinsurgency pre and postminimum force matthew r. Eric hunter haas, major, us army command and general staff college. Communist insurgency in malaysia disambiguation communist insurgency in south korea. Defeating communist insurgency by thompson robert sir abebooks. Experiences from malaya and vietnam, studies in international security. The misapplication of the malayan counterinsurgency model to the.
Setting the stage, malaya, vietnam, and lessons from malaya and vietnam. The conflict was between commonwealth armed forces and pro independence fighters of the malayan national liberation army mnla, the military wing of the malayan communist party mcp. Experiences from malaya and vietnam pdf, in that ramification you outgoing on to the exhibit site. The strategy of counter insurgency stackpole books, harrisberg, 1966. Both the rebellion and the british strategy for countering it bore some similarities to the wartime malayan peoples antijapanese army insurgency of 19421945 and imperial japanese seized hearts counterinsurgency. Defeating communist insurgency experiences from malaya and vietnam studies in international security by robert thompson. Bush tracking and warfare in late twentiethcentury east. Communist insurgency in malaysia 19681989 wikipedia. As defined by the united states army, clear and hold contains three elements.
Darurat malaya was a guerrilla war fought in the federation of malaya from 1948 until 1960. The strategic hamlet program in vietnam was destined to failure because of a misapplication of the malayan counterinsurgency model. This campaign provides a clear example of how to effectively support an allys counterinsurgency efforts with a minimal. Officers from the british effort in afghanistan have observed, as with vietnam, that the afghan insurgency will not be overcome by a doctrine that resembles a stretched version of the malaya campaign mackinlay, 2007. First published in the mid60s, this book is still the one by which all other counterinsurgency books are judged. The british broke the back of the insurgency as a largescale campaign somewhere between 1950 and 1954. Defeating an insurgency the thai effort against the communist party of thailand, 1965ca. British forces are now engaged in a major operation in southern afghanistan, the outcome of which is likely to be strategically decisiveespecially f. Defeating communist insurgency experiences from malaya and vietnam. The communist insurgency in malaysia, also known as the second malayan emergency malay. This article will argue that the classical principles of counterinsurgency, while still exceptionally appropriate for countering regionally dominant insurgencies, are inadequate for countering modern global insurgency, making specific reference to the still present al qaeda. Lessons from malaya and vietnam, chicago and london. One of the ideas addressed in these writings was the denial. I was one of two americans assigned to work with vietnamese special force battling the insurgency in 1971 so my experience is first hand, having worked in the jungles as part of that operation.
The second angloboer war provides the transition for the british army from one of its last colonial warfighting experiences to its first modern counterinsurgency. Stanford libraries official online search tool for books, media, journals, databases, government documents and more. The war in vietnam has been debated and discussed in scores of books and articles from the 1960s until today. The lessons of malaya and vietnam studies in international security. This article will argue that the classical principles of counterinsurgency, while still exceptionally appropriate for countering regionally dominant insurgencies, are inadequate for countering modern global insurgency, making specific reference to the still present al qaeda global.
Small wars manual 1940, government printing office, 1940. Based on his experiences in malaya, sir robert thompson, who served as a consultant in vietnam to the allies, recognized parallels between the british occupation in malaya and the french and american experiences in vietnam. Counterinsurgency lessons from malaya and vietnam chicago. The book is a study of the basic theories of communist insurgency and of. Pdf mootw as a concept that engages military capabilities, falls short of an outright war. The war was fought over attempts by communist forces to gain independence for malaya. Extracts of this book was distributed by the calcutta chief of police to bengali police men in december 1970 during the naxalite insurgency in calcutta. Nagls learning to eat soup with a knife examines what worked in the malayan emergency of 19481960 and what failed in vietnam from 19651972.
Perang insurgensi melawan pengganas komunis or darurat kedua, was an armed conflict which occurred in malaysia from 1968 to 1989, between the malayan communist party mcp and malaysian federal security forces. The concept of kesban in military operations other then war mootw. Jan 01, 2010 while in my youth i had read classic works such asdefeating communist insurgency. Communist insurgency is an umbrella term which may refer to one of several guerrilla conflicts involving communist parties, including. Robert thompson and malaya defeating communist insurgency. Guerrilla warfare is a form of irregular warfare in which small groups of combatants, such as paramilitary personnel, armed civilians, or irregulars, use military tactics including ambushes, sabotage, raids, petty warfare, hit and run tactics, and mobility, to fight a larger and lessmobile traditional military. American military command from world war ii to today by thomas e. Robert thompson, study of the basic theories of communist insurgency, rhodesia, sadf, malaya, vietnam abstract this book was written approximately 16 years ago and much of it is based on the experiences of the author obtained during the insurgencies in malaya and vietnam. Perang insurgensi melawan pengganas komunis or darurat kedua, was an armed conflict which occurred in malaysia from 1968 to 1989, involving the malayan communist party mcp and malaysian federal security forces. The book is a study of the basic theories of communist insurgency and of counter insurgency as they operate on the ground and affect the population of a threatened country. Experiences from malaya and vietnam thompson, sir robert on. Defeating communist insurgency oxford academic journals.
Sir robert thompson has written the most devastating critique of american ineptness in viet nam yet to emerge from the cacophony of shrill and indignant books that have decried. Defeating communist insurgency march 2, 1978 edition open. British experience in defeating the communist insurgency in malaya, has always been cited. Mead judgement on major general o c wingate, dso, written on behalf of the chindits old comrades association in collaboration with liddell hart centre for military archives date unknown. The classical principles of counterinsurgency are inadequate for countering global insurgency. Sir robert thompson was fundamental in establishing counterinsurgency in south vietnam. The war declined in 1980 following the declaration of an amnesty and by 1983 the cpt had abandoned the insurgency.
The malayan emergency as counterinsurgency paradigm. Theory and practice, as well as robert thompson s defeating communist insurgency. Assessing the british counterinsurgency effort in malaya. Thompsons accounts offer invaluable personal insights into the development.
Defeating communist insurgency the lessons of malaya and. In conclusion, the british counter insurgency effort in malaya was a success. The classical principles which will be examined come from david galula s counterinsurgency warfare. Experiences from malaya and vietnam studies in international security robert thompson on. Experiences from malaya and vietnam djvu, pdf, epub, txt.
Defeating an insurgencythe thai effort against the communist party of thailand, 1965ca. Questions about the morality of the united states presence there, whether it could have ever succeeded, and if the strategy was right will probably continue to be answered in a number of ways for many years to come. Experiences from malaya and vietnam djvu, pdf, epub, txt, dr. Clear and hold is a counter insurgency strategy in which military personnel clear an area of guerrillas or other insurgents, and then keep the area clear of insurgents while winning the support of the populace for the government and its policies. A study of agincourt, waterloo, and the somme by john keegan the generals. Counterinsurgency defeating an insurgencythe thai effort. Counterinsurgency lessons from malaya and vietnam with a new preface. War as they knew it, revolutionary war and counterinsurgency in. Vietnam war on the techniques of fighting guerrilla warfare. Pdf the concept of kesban in military operations other then. We move ahead by robert thompson defeating communist insurgency. Books defeating communist insurgency experiences from malaya and vietnam. Communist insurgency in the philippines disambiguation communist insurgency in sarawak. Insurgency, counterinsurgency, and the marines in vietnam.
From 1964 to 1975 a small group of british officers, advisors, and trainers guided the forces of the sultanate of oman to victory in their conflict with the marxist insurgents of the peoples front for the liberation of the occupied arabian gulf pfloag. In iraq, when president bush announced the end of major combat operations on 2. Experiences from malaya and vietnam by sir robert thompson echoes of gallipoli. These books provide detailed firsthand accounts of thompsons experiences in malaya and vietnam. A journey into the soul of iraq, spence publishing company, 2004. Defeating communist insurgency scientia militaria south. Defeating communist insurgency experiences from malaya and. Defeating communist insurgency by thompson robert sir. The ethnic composition of the population, the nature of the insurgency, and the inherent capabilities of the bureaucracy created a unique set of conditions in malaya. Mar 15, 2020 in 1948, the british empire faced an armed communist insurgency in malaya. Techniques of guerrilla warfare, these are now quite dated. The outcome of insurgency and counter insurgency can thus only be explained. See thompson, robert a british adviser in vietnam, defeating communist insurgency. Buy defeating communist insurgency the lessons of malaya and vietnam studies in international security by robert grainger ker thompson isbn.
But it was not until the vietnam war that america faced an insurgency that it could not defeat. Defeating communist insurgency directory of open access. The people are the key base to be secured and defended rather than territory won or enemy bodies counted. This book was written approximately 16 years ago and much of it is based on the experiences of the author obtained during the insurgencies in malaya and vietnam. Experiences from malaya and vietnam and counter insurgency operations. These writers point to numerous guerrilla conflicts that centre around religious, ethnic or even. To study some of the lessons of malaya and vietnam. Based on the authors successful experience in malaya, and his subsequent advisory work for the americans in vietnam, his keys to victory and success have not changed with time. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Defeating communist insurgency by thompson, robert and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at.
1141 1328 1480 1234 1223 216 1321 689 384 1254 1227 123 1432 230 886 1459 628 1406 1441 1321 1277 762 616 1047 190 1284 610 679 216 1324 124 86 1155 756 717 1108 140